Review on Power System Probabilistic Small Signal Stability with High Wind Power Integration

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-7229.2017.07.008

Abstract

Abstract: ABSTRACT： With large-scale development and utilization of renewable power especially wind power, the structure of traditional power system has been changed, and wind power integration has brought new challenges to power system stable operation and control. Based on the characteristics of large-scale wind power, this paper concludes the recent progress and new trends on research of power system probabilistic small signal stability with high wind power integration, and then discusses the control strategy of probabilistic small signal stability wind farm integration when improving power system. Finally, this paper proposes some suggestions for further research in this area, which can provide reference and guidance for the research of the power system probabilistic small signal stability with high wind power integration.

Key words: power system, wind power integration, probabilistic analysis, small signal stability

CLC Number:

TM 712

HE Ping, SHI Feng, YAO Yilin, QU Zhongjie, GENG Sihan . Review on Power System Probabilistic Small Signal Stability with High Wind Power Integration [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2017, 38(7): 59-.

References

［1］Global wind energy outlook 2016 ［EB/OL］. ［2017-06-28］. http://www. gwec.net/publications/global-wind-energy-outlook/global-w-ind-energy-outlook-2016/

［2］FRERIS L, INFIELD D. Renewable energy in power systems［M］. New York: Wiley, 2008.

［3］王仲颖. 中国风电发展路线图2050 ［R］. 北京: 国家发改委能源研究所, 2011.

［4］国家能源局.可再生能源发展“十二五”规划［EB/OL］. http://www.nea.gov.cn/2012-08/08/c_131767651.html,2012-08-08.

［5］Global wind statistics 2014［R］. Brussels: Global Wind Energy Council, 2015.

［6］商立峰.中国风电发展路径研究［D］.天津:天津大学,2013. SHANG Lifeng,Research developmet path windpower China［D］. Tianjin: Tianjin University, 2013.

［7］SU C, HU W H, CHEN Z, et al. Mitigation of power system oscillation caused by wind power fluctuation ［J］. IET Renewable Power Generation, 2013, 7（6）:639-651.

［8］余贻鑫. 智能电网的核心理念［C］// 2014年第四届北京国际储能大会. 北京， 2014.

［9］朱方, 赵红光, 刘增煌, 等.大区电网互联对电力系统动态稳定性的影响［J］.中国电机工程学报, 2007, 27（1）: 1-7. ZHU Fang, ZHAO Hongguang, LIU Zenghuang, et al.The influence of large power grid interconnected on power system dynamic stability［J］. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2007, 27（1）: 1-7.

［10］GNTHER B, DUSAN P, DIETMAR R, et al. 全球大停电的经验教训［J］. 中国电力, 2007, 40（10）: 75-81. GNTHER B, DUSAN P, DIETMAR R, et al. Lessons from the global blackout［J］. Electric Power, 2007, 40（10）: 75-81.

［11］ARULAMPALAM A, TAPAN K. Power system blackouts-literature review［C］//Fourth International Conference on Industrial and Information Systems（ICIIS 2009）. Sri Lanka, 2009: 460-465.

［12］中国电力企业联合会. 全国电力工业统计快报（2011 年）［EB/OL］. （2012-01-13）［2017-03-27］. http://www.cec.org.cn/xinxifabu/2012-01-13/78769. html.

［13］贺德馨.中国风能发展战略研究［J］.中国工程科学, 2011,13（6）:95-100. HE Dexin. Research on Chinas wind energy development strategy ［J］. Engineering Science,2011,13（6）:95-100.

［14］WANG Z, QIN H, LEWIS JI. Chinas wind power industry: policy support, technological achievements, and emerging challenges ［J］. Energy Policy, 2012, 51（C）:80-88.

［15］费智,符平.我国风电发展的态势分析与对策建议［J］.科技进步与对策,2011, 28（10）:65-68. FEI Zhi, FU Ping.The status quo and future policy of Chinese wind power development［J］. Science & Technology Progress and Policy,2011, 28（10）:65-68.

［16］LIU Y, KOKKO A. Wind power in China: Policy and development challenges ［J］.Energy Policy,2010, 38（10）: 5520- 5529.

［17］2014中国风电发展报告［R］.北京:中国循环经济协会可再生能源专业委员会,2014.

［18］李俊峰.2012中国风电发展报告［R］.北京:中国风能协会,2012.

［19］International Energy Agency. Variability of wind power and other renewables:management options and strategies［R］. Paris: International Energy Agency, 2005.

［20］周双喜,朱凌志,郭锡玖,等.电力系统电压稳定性及其控制［M］.北京:中国电力出版社,2003.

［21］ECHAVARREN F M, LOBATO E, ROUCO L, et al. Formulation, computation and improvement of steady state security margins in power systems. Part I: Theoretical framework ［J］. International Journal of Electr Power Energy Systems,2011,33（ 2）: 340-346.

［22］毛安家,张戈力,吕跃春,等. 2011年9月8日美墨大停电事故的分析及其对我国电力调度运行管理的启示［J］. 电网技术,2012,36（4）:74-78. MAO Anjia, ZHANG Geli, LYU Yuechun, et al.Analysis on large-scale blackout occurred in south America and North Mexico interconnected power grid on Sept. 8, 2011 and lessons for electric power dispatching in China［J］. Power System Technology, 2012,36（4）:74-78.

［23］汤涌,卜广全,易俊. 印度“7.30”、“7.31”大停电事故分析及启示［J］. 中国电机工程学报,2012,32（25）:167-174, 23. TANG Yong, BU Guangquan, YI Jun.Analysis and lessons of the blackout in Indian power grid on July 30 and 31［J］. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2012,32（25）:167-174, 23.

［24］唐斯庆,张弥,李建设,等. 海南电网“9·26"大面积停电事故的分析与总结［J］. 电力系统自动化,2006,30（1）:1-7, 16. TANG Siqing, ZHANG Mi,LI Jianshe, et al. Review of blackout in Hainan on September 26th causes and recommendations［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2006,30（1）:1-7, 16.

［25］李春艳,孙元章,陈向宜,等. 西欧“11.4”大停电事故的初步分析及防止我国大面积停电事故的措施［J］. 电网技术,2006,30（24）:16-21. LI Chunyan, SUN Yuanzhang, CHEN Xiangyi, et al.Preliminary analysis of large scale blackout in Western Europe power grid on November 4 and measures to prevent large scale blackout in China［J］. Power System Technology, 2006,30（24）:16-21.

［26］林伟芳,汤涌,孙华东,等. 巴西“2·4”大停电事故及对电网安全稳定运行的启示［J］. 电力系统自动化,2011,35（9）:1-5. LIN Weifang, TANG Yong, SUN Huadong, et al. Blackout in Brazil power grid on February 4, 2011 and inspration for stable operation of power grid［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems,2011,35（9）:1-5.

［27］林伟芳,孙华东,汤涌,等. 巴西“11·10”大停电事故分析及启示［J］. 电力系统自动化,2010,34（7）:1-5. LIN Weifang, SUN Huadong, TANG Yong , et al.Analysis and lessons of the blackout in Brazil power grid on November 10, 2009［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2010,34（7）:1-5.

［28］KUNDUN P, PASERBA J, AJJARAPU V, et al. Definition and classification of power system stability［J］. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2004,19（2）:1387-1401.

［29］范伟,赵书强. 考虑风力发电的电力系统小干扰稳定性分析［J］. 华北电力大学学报（自然科学版）, 2009, 36（2）: 23-27, 32. FAN Wei, ZHAO Shuqiang.Small signal stability analysis of power system considering wind farm［J］. Journal of North China Electric Power University（Natural Science Edition）, 2009,36（2）:23-27, 32.

［30］王克文,钟志勇,谢志棠,等.混合使用中心矩与累加量的电力系统概率特征根分析方法［J］.中国电机工程学报,2000,20 （5）:37-41. WANG Kewen, ZHONG Zhiyong, XIE Zhitang, et al. A hybird algorithm using moment and cumulant for power system probabilistic eigenvalue analysis［J］.Proceedings of the CSEE, 2000,20 （5）:37-41.

［31］BURCHETT R C, HEYDT G T. Probabilistic methods for power system dynamic stability studies［J］.IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems,1978,97（3）:695-702.

［32］胡金磊,张尧,陈延秋,等. 基于解析法的概率暂态稳定扰动后初值计算［J］. 电力自动化设备,2008,28（11）:17-21. HU Jinlei, ZHANG Yao, CHEN Yanqiu, et al.Calculation of post disturbance initial value for probabilistic transient stability analysis based on multi operating conditions［J］. Electric Power Automation Equipment, 2008,28（11）:17-21.

［33］LI Wenyuan. Risk assessment of power systems: models, methods, and applications［J］. Interfaces, 2005, 36（2）:179-180.

［34］XU Z, DONG Z Y, ZHANG P. Probabilistic small signal analysis using Monte Carlo simulation［C］// Proceedings of IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting, San Francisco: IEEE, 2005: 1658-1664.

［35］雷桂媛. 关于蒙特卡罗及拟蒙特卡罗方法的若干研究［D］.杭州:浙江大学,2003. LEI Guiyuan. Studies on Monte Carlo and Quasi-Monte Carlo methods［D］. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University, 2003.

［36］朱辉,刘义保,游运. 蒙特卡罗方法与拟蒙特卡罗方法的历史、现状及展望［J］. 东华理工大学学报（自然科学版）,2010,33（4）:357-362. ZHU Hui, LIU Yibao, YOU Yun.Monte Carlo method and quasi-Monte Carlo method［J］. Journal of East China Institute of Technology（Natural Science Edition）, 2010,33（4）:357-362.

［37］侯雨伸,王秀丽,刘杰,等. 基于拟蒙特卡罗方法的电力系统可靠性评估［J］. 电网技术,2015,39（3）:744-750. HOU Yushen, WANG Xiuli, LIU Jie, et al.A quasi-Monte Carlo method based power system reliability evaluation［J］. Power System Technology, 2015,39（3）:744-750.

［38］张建华,王昕伟,蒋程,等. 基于蒙特卡罗方法的风电场有功出力的概率性评估［J］. 电力系统保护与控制,2014,42（3）:82-87. ZHANG Jianhua, WANG Xinwei, JIANG Cheng, et al. Probabilistic assessment of wind farm active power based on Monte-Carlo simulation［J］. Power System Protection and Control, 2014,42（3）:82-87.

［39］于晗, 钟志勇, 黄杰波, 等. 采用拉丁超立方采样的电力系统概率潮流计算方法［J］. 电力系统自动化, 2009, 33（21）:32-36. YU Han, ZHONG Zhiyong, HUANG Jiebo, et al.A probabilistic load flow calculation method with Latin Hypercube sampling［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2009, 33（21）:32-36.

［40］吴义纯, 丁明. 基于蒙特卡罗仿真的风力发电系统可靠性评价［J］. 电力自动化设备, 2004, 24（12）: 70-73. WU Yichun, DING Ming. Reliability assessment of wind power generation system based onMonte Carlo simulation［J］. Electric Power Automation Equipment, 2004, 24（12）: 70-73.

［41］李媛媛,邱跃丰,马世英,等.风电机组接入对系统小干扰稳定性的影响研究［J］.电网技术,2010,36（8）:50-55. LI Yuanyuan, QIU Yuefeng, MA Shiying, et al.Impact of grid-connected wind turbine generators on small signal stability of power grid［J］. Power System Technology, 2010,36（8）: 50-55.

［42］HE Ping, WEN Fushuan, GERARD L, et al. Investigations on the impacts of various types of wind turbine generators on power system stability［J］. Journal of Energy Engineering, 2015, 141（3）：1-10.

［43］和萍, 文福拴, 薛禹胜, 等. 风电场并网对互联系统小干扰稳定及低频振荡特性的影响［J］. 电力系统自动化, 2014,38（22）:1-10. HE Ping, WEN Fushuan, XUE Yusheng, et al. Impact of wind power integration on small signal stability and low frequency oscillation characteristics of interconnected power systems［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2014,38（22）:1-10.

［44］孙延昭.永磁直驱风电变流系统控制策略研究［D］.长沙:湖南大学,2009. SUN Yanzhao.The research on control strategies in permanent-magnet direct-driven wind power conversion system［D］. Changsha: Hunan University, 2009.

［45］WANG Chen, SHI Libao, WANG Liming, et al. Modelling analysis in power system small signal stability with grid-connected wind farms of DFIG type［J］.Wind Engineering,2008, 32（3）: 243-264.

［46］伍红,赵霞,周家启.电力系统小扰动概率稳定性的蒙特卡罗仿真［J］.电力系统自动化,2009,33（11）:8-12. WU Hong, ZHAO Xia, ZHOU Jiaqi.Monte Carlo simulation of probabilistic small disturbance stability［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2009,33（11）:8-12.

［47］史文丽.风电接入的电力系统静态安全概率分析［J］.电气开关,2013,51（5）:48-51. SHI Wenli.Static security probability analysis for the power system with wind power［J］. Electrical Switch, 2013,51（5）:48-51.

［48］边晓燕,李广跃,王克文,等.多运行方式下含风电场电力系统的小干扰概率稳定性研究［J］.电网技术,2013,37（11）: 3046- 3054. BIAN Xiaoyan, LI Guangyue, WANG Kewen, et al.Probabilistic small signal stability analysis of power system integrated with large-scale wind farm considering multi operating conditions［J］. Power System Technology, 2013,37（11）: 3046-3054.

［49］杜文娟,卜思齐,王海风. 考虑并网风电随机波动的电力系统小干扰概率稳定性分析［J］.中国电机工程学报， 2011,31（s1）:7-11. DU Wenjuan, BU Siqi, WANG Haifeng.Effect of stochastic variation of grid-connected wind generation on power system small-signal probabilistic stability［J］. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2011,31（s1）:7-11.

［50］BU S Q, DU W, WANG H F, et al. Probabilistic analysis of small-signal stability of large-scale power systems as affected by penetration of wind generation［J］.IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2012, 27（2）: 762-770.

［51］黄海煜,于文娟.考虑风电出力概率分布的电力系统可靠性评估［J］.电网技术.2013,37（9）:2586-2591. HUANG Haiyu, YU Wenjuan.Power grid reliability assessment considering probability distribution of wind farm power output［J］. Power System Technology, 2013,37（9）: 2586-2591.

［52］GAUTAM D, VITTAL V, HARBOUR T. Impact of increased penetration of DFIG-based wind turbine generations on transient and small signal stability of power systems［J］. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 2012, 24（3）: 1426-1434.

［53］ABDELHALIM H, FARID A M, ADEGBEGE A A, et al. Small-signal stability effects of turbine governors on power systems with high penetrations of integrated wind power［C］//Innovative Smart Grid Technologies （ISGT） . IEEE, 2013:1-6.

［54］ISWADI H R, MORROW D J, BEST R J. Small signal stability performance of power system during high penetration of wind generation［C］//Power Engineering Conference （UPEC）, 2014 49th International Universities. 2014:1-6.

［55］李军军, 吴政球, 谭勋琼. 下垂特性对直驱永磁风电系统的小扰动稳定影响［J］. 中国电机工程学报, 2011, 31（3）: 52-59. LI Junjun, WU Zhengqiu, TAN Xunqiong.Droop characteristics effect on small signal stability of directly driven permanent magnet wind power system［J］. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2011, 31（3）: 52-59.

［56］李辉, 张志科, 杨超, 等. 双馈风电机组参数及运行状态的小干扰稳定性分析［J］. 电机与控制学报, 2013, 17（2）: 14-21. LI Hui, ZHANG Zhike, YANG Chao, et al.Analysis of parameter and operation state on small-signal stability of doubly-fed wind turbine generation system［J］. Electric Machines and Control, 2013, 17（2）: 14-21.

［57］石佳莹, 沈沉, 刘锋. 双馈风电机组动力学特性对电力系统小干扰稳定的影响分析［J］. 电力系统自动化, 2013, 37（18）: 7-13. SHI Jiaying, SHEN Chen, LIU Feng. Analysis on impact of DFIG wind turbines dynamic characteristics on power systems small signal stability［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2013, 37（18）: 7-13.

［58］VITTAL E, OMALLEY M, KEANE A. Rotor angle stability with high penetrations of wind generation［J］. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems , 2012, 27（1）: 353-362.

［59］和萍, 文福拴, LEDWICH G，等. 附加阻尼控制静止无功补偿器对含风电互联系统阻尼特性的影响［J］. 华北电力大学学报, 2014, 41（2）:6-14. HE Ping, WEN Fushuan, LEDWICH G, et al. Impacts of ADC-SVC on damping characteristics of interconnected power systems with wind farms［J］. Journal of North China Electric Power University, 2014, 41（2）:6-14.

［60］关宏亮, 迟永宁, 戴慧珠, 等. 并网风电场改善系统阻尼的仿真［J］. 电力系统自动化, 2008, 32（13）: 81-85. GUAN Hongliang, CHI Yongning, DAI Huizhu, et al.A simulation on wind farm integration in improving power system damping［J］. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2008, 32（13）: 81-85.

［61］云雷, 刘涤尘, 廖清芬, 等. 基于功率分布法分析和控制区间联络线功率振荡［J］. 电力系统自动化, 2012, 36（10）: 7-13. YUN Lei, LIU Dichen, LIAO Qingfen, et al. Analysis and control of interval tie line power oscillations based on power distribution method［J］. Automation of electric power systems, 2012, 36（10）: 7-13.

［62］王成福, 梁军, 张利, 等. 基于静止同步补偿器的风电场无功电压控制策略［J］. 中国电机工程学报, 2010, 30（25）: 23-28. WANG Chengfu, LIANG Jun, ZHANG Li, et al.Reactive power and voltage control strategy for wind farm based on STATCOM［J］. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2010, 30（25）: 23-28.

［63］JAUCH C, CRONIN T, SORENSEN P, et al. A fuzzy logic pitch angle controller for power system stabilization［J］. Wind Energy, 2007, 10（1）: 19-30.

［64］YANG L, YANG G Y, XU Z, et al. Optimal controller design of a doubly-fed induction generator wind turbine system for small signal stability enhancement［J］. IET Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 2010, 4（5）: 579-597.

［65］WU F, ZHANG X P, GODFREY K, et al. Small signal stability analysis and optimal control of a wind turbine with doubly fed induction generator ［J］. IET Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 2007, 1（5）: 751-760.

［66］KASSEM A M, HASANEEN K M, YOUSEF A M. Dynamic modeling and robust power control of DFIG driven by wind turbine at infinite grid ［J］. International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems, 2013, 44（1）: 375-382.

［67］李国庆,马建功,裴建楠.基于拉丁超立方采样的含风电小干扰稳定概率分析［J］.黑龙江电力,2015, 37（1）:5-9. LI Guoqing, MA Jiangong, PEI Jiannan.Probabilistic analysis of small signal stability with wind power based on Latin Hypercube sampling［J］. Heilongjiang Electric Power, 2015, 37（1）:5-9.

[1]	TAN Qinliang, DING Yihong, LI Yu, LI Rui. Multi-objective Optimization of Combined Wind-Solar-Thermal Power Dispatching Strategy Considering Economic-Environmental Equilibrium [J]. ELECTRIC POWER CONSTRUCTION, 2020, 41(8): 129-136.
[2]	FANG Chaoxiong， WU Xiaosheng， JIANG Yuewen. Research on Multi-Objective Bi-Level Optimization of Network-Storage Considering Transient Stability [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(7): 58-66.
[3]	LI Huaqu1，XIAO Jinsong1，SHU Zhan2，ZHANG Zheng1，YAO Liangzhong1，PENG Xiaotao1. Point-Estimation Based Method for Optimizing Both Location and Capacity of Grid-Connected Wind Farm [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(4): 109-116.
[4]	LIANG Xiurui, LIU Daowei, YANG Hongying, LI Weixing, SHAO Guanghui, XU Xingwei, WANG Kefei, LI Zonghan, ZHAO Gaoshang. Data-Driven Situation Assessment of Power System Static Voltage Stability [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2020, 41(1): 126-132.
[5]	LIU Yingqi, XIE Min, WEI Wei, ZHANG Yue, LIU Mingbo. Assessment and Optimization for Power System Flexibility with High Proportion of Wind Power [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(9): 1-10.
[6]	HUAN Jiajia， SUI Yu， ZHANG Xiaohui. Analysis Method for Cascade Failure and Fault Chain Reaction of Integrated Energy System [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(8): 84-92.
[7]	YANG Linchao， LOU Boliang， XU Zheng， ZHOU Hua， HUA Wen. A Dynamic Equivalent Method for Three-Sequence Network Applied to Electromagnetic Transient Simulation of AC/DC System and Its Application in East China Power Grid [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(7): 57-64.
[8]	LI Gang，HUANG Peishuo，CHEN Yixiao，ZHENG Guping. Security Situation Assessment Method for Cyber Physical Power System Considering Threat Propagation Characteristics [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(5): 29-37.
[9]	CAI Xingpu， WANG Qi， TAI Wei， LIU Keyan. A Multi-Stage Game Based Defense Method against False Data Injection Attack on Cyber Physical Power System [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(5): 48-54.
[10]	HU Jiahua， WEN Fushuan， MA Li， PENG Shengjiang，FAN Menghua，XU Haoliang. Power System Operation Flexibility and Flexible Ramping Products [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(4): 70-80.
[11]	LI Ping， WANG Chunsheng， MU Yongqiang， WANG Haixia， CHANG Youyi， ZHANG Gengyu， LIU Aimin， LI Weidong. Regression Model for Dynamic Thermal Performance of the District Heating System and Combined Heat and Power Dispatch [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(3): 17-26.
[12]	CHEN Fei， FENG Hao， XU Chenbo， SUN Feifei. Investigationon of Internal Driving Factors and Development Path in Power System Evolution [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(3): 59-66.
[13]	LIN Hongji， YAN Yuan， WEN Fushuan， HU Jiahua， QU Haoyuan， ZHAO Zheng. Real-Time Dispatch Considering Flexible Ramping Products in A Power System with High Proportion of Renewable Energy Generation [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(10): 18-27.
[14]	YANG Zhichao， SUN Lei， DING Ming. Optimization Strategy for Start-up Sequence of Generation Units Considering Critical Restoration Paths [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(10): 28-35.
[15]	YANG Bowen， XIE Xiaorong， YAN Gangui， ZHAN Ying. Review of Subsynchronous Oscillation Analysis Method for On-Grid Wind Power Systems [J]. Electric Power Construction, 2019, 40(10): 56-63.